Skip to main content
Support

Browse by category

All categories
Fermentation Atlas

Cereals and bread from Botswana and South Africa

Ting and bogobe (Botswana sorghum)ting

Dehulled sorghum meal is mixed with lukewarm water and left closed until lactic acid bacteria sour it. The sour slurry is called ting. Boiled in water it becomes bogobe jwa ting, a soft sour porridge eaten thin with sugar at breakfast or thick with meat or vegetables. Made in 4 steps over 24 h – 3 days. The longest step, ferment the slurry, covered, takes 24 h – 3 days (Haard N.F. et al. 1999) and runs at 28–34 °C (Rapoo S.M 2023). Lactobacilli (Lactobacillus fermentum, L. reuteri, L. plantarum, L. harbinensis, L. parabuchneri, L. casei, L. coryniformis), 2–4 dominant strains per sample and Lactococcus lactis, Weissella cibaria, Enterococcus faecalis and Lactobacillus rhamnosus in the acid phase do most of the fermenting.

Key numbers
Main step24 h – 3 daysReported[fao1999][sekwati2011][rapoo2023]Ferment the slurry, covered
Temperature28–34 °CReported[rapoo2023][adebo2019]Ferment the slurry, covered
AciditypH 3.5–4Measured[sekwati2011]Ferment the slurry, covered
Fully documentedCereals and bread24 h – 3 daysMore cereals and breadMore from Africa

Recipe

Amounts from a sourceFAO's flow diagram gives proportions, not amounts: meal and lukewarm water 1:1 (w/v). A lab version used 50 g of whole-grain sorghum flour with water at 40 °C, 1:1 (w/v).
1 part by weightCoarse dehulled sorghum meal · Grain washed, dehulled and the bran discarded before grinding[fao1999]
1 part by volumeLukewarm water · Meal to water 1:1 (w/v)[fao1999]
OptionalSome of a previous good batch (back-slopping), or vinegar in some households · Used to speed or steady the souring[rapoo2023]
To tasteSugar, or a relish of meat, vegetables or beans · For serving[rapoo2023]
Starterspontaneous; some households back-slop from a previous batch

Total time across the recorded steps: 24 h – 3 days

Start
Drag the bar or press Play

What changes: Washed sorghum is dehulled and ground into a coarse meal

Step 1 of 4
Wash, dehull and grind the sorghum
Time
Not documented
Temperature
Not documented
Salt
None given
Acidity
Not documented
Which microbes the steps name, step by step
Enterococcus mundtii
Lactic acid bacteria

Output: coarse sorghum meal, bran discarded.

Flavour
Not documented
Texture
Not documented
Colour
Not documented

Microbes at work in this step

Not documented for this step.

Method

Measured measured in a studySet fixed by a specification or tested recipeReported one source reports itTypical a general value, not sourced for this fermentUnconfirmed not yet checked against a source

What makes this one different

Ting is the sour sorghum slurry and bogobe jwa ting the porridge cooked from it. Unlike ogi, the grain is not steeped and wet-sieved; dry meal is simply mixed with water and soured. Bogobe made without fermenting is a different, thick porridge called monokwane.

Related ferments

Variants

  • MonokwaneThick sorghum porridge made without fermentation.
  • Starter-culture tingPairs of lactobacilli isolated from ting lowered the pH from 6.3 to 4 within 8 h, instead of 2 to 3 days.
  • Whole-grain tingMade from whole, not dehulled, sorghum flour in lab studies.

Safety

Traditional ting reaches pH below 4 after 2 to 3 days, and Enterobacteriaceae fell below 10 cfu/g in finished samples. Sorghum can carry fumonisins and other mycotoxins; in one study fermentation lowered them but did not remove them, so start from clean, sound grain. The porridge is boiled before it is eaten.

Hazards the sources name: Mycotoxins from moulds on the grain (fumonisins B1–B3, T-2 toxin, zearalenone); lowered but not removed by fermentation.

History and sources

Every number is labelled with how it is known. How this atlas is made

  1. [fao1999] Haard N.F. et al. 1999, Fermented cereals. A global perspective, chapter 2, Cereal fermentations in African countries (bogobe, Fig. 11), FAO Agricultural Services Bulletin 138gov
  2. [sekwati2011] Sekwati-Monang B., Gänzle M.G. 2011, Microbiological and chemical characterisation of ting, a sorghum-based sourdough product from Botswana, International Journal of Food Microbiology (abstract)paper
  3. [madoroba2011] Madoroba E. et al. 2011, Diversity and dynamics of bacterial populations during spontaneous sorghum fermentations used to produce ting, a South African food, Systematic and Applied Microbiology (abstract)paper
  4. [rapoo2023] Rapoo S.M., Budeli P., Thaoge M.L. 2023, Recovery of potential starter cultures and probiotics from fermented sorghum (ting) slurries, Microorganisms 11:715paper
  5. [adebo2019] Adebo O.A., Kayitesi E., Njobeh P.B. 2019, Reduction of mycotoxins during fermentation of whole grain sorghum to whole grain ting (a southern African food), Toxins 11:180paper